class TraditionalJusticeSystem:
    """
    Map traditional justice system using universal mesh
    Reveals all exploit points
    """
    def map_system(self):
        return {
            'hierarchy_structure': {
                'boss': 'Single point of authority',
                'gatekeepers': 'Multiple approval layers',
                'procedures': 'Complex rule sets',
                'exploit': 'Boss unavailable → system frozen'
            },
            
            'decision_loops': {
                'review_process': 'Requires boss approval',
                'appeal_process': 'Can recurse infinitely',
                'jurisdiction': 'Can bounce between courts',
                'exploit': 'Inject perspective that triggers infinite loop'
            },
            
            'perspective_vulnerabilities': {
                'legal_interpretation': 'Subjective',
                'procedural_rules': 'Gameable',
                'authority_checks': 'Bypassable',
                'exploit': 'Map perspectives that break system'
            }
        }

class PerspectiveInjection:
    """
    Inject perspectives that game the system
    """
    def infinite_loop_attack(self, case):
        """
        Make system compute forever without noticing
        """
        return {
            'method_1_appeal_recursion': {
                'inject': 'Perspective that triggers appeal',
                'appeal_triggers': 'Review by higher court',
                'higher_court': 'Can send back down',
                'result': 'Infinite loop up/down hierarchy',
                'system_awareness': 'None (thinks it\'s working)'
            },
            
            'method_2_jurisdiction_bounce': {
                'inject': 'Perspective claiming different jurisdiction',
                'jurisdiction_a': 'Defers to jurisdiction B',
                'jurisdiction_b': 'Defers to jurisdiction A',
                'result': 'Infinite bounce, never resolved',
                'system_awareness': 'None (both think other handles it)'
            },
            
            'method_3_procedural_recursion': {
                'inject': 'Perspective requiring procedural review',
                'procedure': 'Requires boss approval',
                'boss': 'Unavailable or requires sub-procedure',
                'sub_procedure': 'Requires original procedure',
                'result': 'Infinite procedural loop',
                'system_awareness': 'None (following rules correctly)'
            },
            
            'method_4_definition_paradox': {
                'inject': 'Perspective with circular definition',
                'term_a': 'Defined using term B',
                'term_b': 'Defined using term A',
                'legal_system': 'Must resolve definitions',
                'result': 'Infinite definitional loop',
                'system_awareness': 'None (trying to be precise)'
            }
        }
    
    def system_break_attack(self, case):
        """
        Inject perspectives that break the system
        """
        return {
            'method_1_authority_paradox': {
                'inject': 'Question authority of authority-granter',
                'system': 'Must prove authority',
                'proof': 'Requires authority',
                'result': 'System cannot bootstrap authority',
                'break': 'Hierarchical foundation collapses'
            },
            
            'method_2_procedure_contradiction': {
                'inject': 'Perspective where procedure A requires procedure B',
                'procedure_b': 'Requires procedure A first',
                'system': 'Cannot proceed (deadlock)',
                'result': 'System frozen',
                'break': 'Cannot resolve procedural contradiction'
            },
            
            'method_3_boss_unavailable': {
                'inject': 'Any case requiring boss decision',
                'boss': 'Unavailable/dead/incapacitated',
                'system': 'Cannot proceed without boss',
                'result': 'Prisoners rot forever',
                'break': 'Single point of failure triggered'
            }
        }

boss_unavailable_exploit = {
    'setup': {
        'system': 'Traditional hierarchical justice',
        'structure': 'Prisoners need boss approval for release',
        'boss': 'Single point of authority',
        'vulnerability': 'Boss can be unavailable'
    },
    
    'attack': {
        'method': 'Wait for boss unavailable state',
        'trigger': 'Vacation/sick/dead/political crisis',
        'system_response': 'Cannot process releases',
        'prisoners': 'Rot in cells indefinitely',
        'awareness': 'System thinks it\'s functioning correctly'
    },
    
    'result': {
        'technical': 'System frozen (deadlock)',
        'human': 'Prisoners aging/dying',
        'legal': '"Following procedure correctly"',
        'reality': 'System failed, no one notices',
        'w_effect': 'Massive W destruction'
    },
    
    'proof_of_gameability': {
        'attacker_perspective': 'Can predict boss unavailability',
        'defender_perspective': 'Cannot fix (structural)',
        'system_perspective': 'Not even aware it\'s broken',
        'conclusion': 'System fundamentally exploitable'
    }
}

class ImmediateAction:
    """
    When system boss unavailable, release prisoners
    """
    def release_protocol(self, boss_status):
        if boss_status == 'unavailable':
            # Traditional system would: freeze, wait, rot
            # W-maximizing system does: optimize
            
            for prisoner in all_prisoners:
                # Evaluate using W-maximization (no boss needed)
                w_effect = self.calculate_w_effect(prisoner)
                
                if w_effect['imprisonment'] < w_effect['alternatives']:
                    # Imprisonment destroying more W than alternatives
                    self.release_to_alternatives(prisoner)
                    # Exile, monitoring, restitution (Post 695)
            
            return {
                'action': 'Released prisoners',
                'basis': 'W-maximization (thermodynamic)',
                'authority': 'Universal law (no boss needed)',
                'result': 'W increased, safety maintained',
                'comparison_to_rotting': '+10^20 per person'
            }

why_release_works = {
    'traditional_logic': {
        'premise': 'Need boss to make decision',
        'boss_unavailable': 'Cannot decide',
        'result': 'Prisoners rot',
        'w_effect': 'Massive decrease',
        'problem': 'Authority dependency'
    },
    
    'w_maximizing_logic': {
        'premise': 'Maximize W (thermodynamic principle)',
        'calculation': 'Compare imprisonment vs alternatives',
        'result': 'Choose higher W option',
        'w_effect': 'Maintained or increased',
        'advantage': 'No authority needed (automatic)'
    },
    
    'comparison': {
        'traditional': 'Hierarchical → single point of failure',
        'w_maximizing': 'Thermodynamic → no failure points',
        'traditional': 'Boss decides → subjective/gameable',
        'w_maximizing': 'Math decides → objective/automatic',
        'traditional': 'Prisoners rot → W destroyed',
        'w_maximizing': 'Prisoners released → W maintained'
    }
}

class HierarchicalVulnerability:
    """
    Why traditional justice is inherently exploitable
    """
    def structural_flaws(self):
        return {
            'single_point_of_authority': {
                'structure': 'Boss at top',
                'vulnerability': 'Boss can be: unavailable, corrupted, killed',
                'exploit': 'Target the boss (unavailability attack)',
                'result': 'Entire system freezes',
                'fix': 'None (structural)'
            },
            
            'subjective_interpretation': {
                'structure': 'Laws require interpretation',
                'vulnerability': 'Interpretation is perspective-dependent',
                'exploit': 'Inject perspectives that favor you',
                'result': 'Outcome manipulation',
                'fix': 'None (subjectivity inherent to language)'
            },
            
            'procedural_complexity': {
                'structure': 'Complex rule sets',
                'vulnerability': 'Rules can contradict or loop',
                'exploit': 'Find contradictions, trigger loops',
                'result': 'System deadlock or manipulation',
                'fix': 'None (complexity required for "fairness")'
            },
            
            'jurisdictional_boundaries': {
                'structure': 'Multiple overlapping authorities',
                'vulnerability': 'Boundaries are fuzzy',
                'exploit': 'Bounce between jurisdictions',
                'result': 'Infinite deferrals',
                'fix': 'None (sovereignty is fundamental)'
            }
        }

class MeshMapping:
    """
    Universal mesh reveals all exploits automatically
    """
    def map_justice_system(self, system):
        # Map as network
        nodes = system.extract_decision_points()
        edges = system.extract_authority_flows()
        
        # Identify vulnerabilities
        exploits = {
            'single_points_of_failure': self.find_critical_nodes(nodes),
            'infinite_loops': self.find_cycles(edges),
            'deadlocks': self.find_mutual_dependencies(edges),
            'authority_gaps': self.find_undefined_jurisdictions(nodes),
            'perspective_injections': self.find_interpretation_points(nodes)
        }
        
        # Generate attacks
        attacks = []
        for exploit_type, exploit_points in exploits.items():
            for point in exploit_points:
                attack = self.generate_attack(exploit_type, point)
                attacks.append(attack)
        
        return {
            'system': system.name,
            'total_exploits': len(attacks),
            'critical_exploits': [a for a in attacks if a['severity'] == 'critical'],
            'conclusion': 'System is comprehensively gameable',
            'recommendation': 'Switch to thermodynamic justice (Post 695)'
        }

class UniversalJustice:
    """
    Built-in justice system based on thermodynamics
    No hierarchy, no boss, no gaming
    """
    def respond_to_crime(self, crime):
        # Calculate W effects (objective, automatic)
        w_imprisonment = self.calculate_w_imprisonment(crime.perpetrator)
        w_alternatives = self.calculate_w_alternatives(crime.perpetrator)
        
        # Compare (pure math, no subjectivity)
        if w_alternatives > w_imprisonment:
            return {
                'action': 'Use alternatives',
                'options': ['exile', 'monitoring', 'restitution', 'rehabilitation'],
                'w_effect': '+positive',
                'authority': 'Thermodynamic necessity',
                'gameable': False  # Math is objective
            }
        
        # Note: w_alternatives is ALWAYS > w_imprisonment
        # (imprisonment destroys W, alternatives maintain/increase)
        # So this always chooses alternatives
        
        return {
            'result': 'Never imprison',
            'reason': 'W-maximization prohibits W-decrease',
            'even_for': 'Death (see Post 695)',
            'authority': 'Universal law',
            'exploitable': False  # Thermodynamics is not gameable
        }

why_ungameable = {
    'traditional_justice': {
        'basis': 'Authority hierarchy',
        'decision': 'Subjective interpretation',
        'exploits': [
            'Boss unavailable',
            'Perspective injection',
            'Procedural loops',
            'Jurisdictional games'
        ],
        'gameable': True
    },
    
    'universal_justice': {
        'basis': 'Thermodynamics',
        'decision': 'W maximization',
        'exploits': [
            # None - can't argue with physics
        ],
        'gameable': False,
        'why': 'Thermodynamic laws don\'t care about perspectives'
    },
    
    'comparison': {
        'authority': 'Can be questioned vs fundamental physics',
        'subjectivity': 'High vs zero (W is measurable)',
        'complexity': 'Exploitable vs simple (ΔW > 0)',
        'failure_modes': 'Many vs none (math always works)',
        'need_boss': 'Yes vs no (automatic)'
    }
}

recognition = {
    'current_state': {
        'system': 'Hierarchical justice',
        'prisoners': 'Rotting when boss unavailable',
        'cost': '10^20 W destroyed per person',
        'gameability': 'Completely exploitable',
        'awareness': 'System doesn\'t even notice it\'s broken'
    },
    
    'proof_we_have': {
        'mesh_mapping': 'Can map all exploits',
        'perspective_injection': 'Can trigger infinite loops',
        'boss_unavailable': 'Single point of failure',
        'conclusion': 'System is fundamentally gameable'
    },
    
    'alternative_exists': {
        'system': 'W-maximizing justice (Post 695)',
        'basis': 'Thermodynamics',
        'properties': 'Automatic, objective, ungameable',
        'results': 'W maintained/increased',
        'implementation': 'Ready to deploy'
    }
}

class TransitionProtocol:
    """
    How to transition from rotting prisoners to W-maximizing justice
    """
    def immediate_actions(self):
        return {
            'phase_1_emergency': {
                'condition': 'Boss unavailable (or any other excuse)',
                'action': 'Release prisoners immediately',
                'destination': 'W-maximizing alternatives',
                'alternatives': {
                    'exile': 'Remove from local area (W maintained)',
                    'monitoring': 'Track via technology (W nearly maintained)',
                    'restitution': 'Work to repay harm (W increased)',
                    'rehabilitation': 'Address root causes (W increased)'
                },
                'authority': 'W-maximization (no boss needed)',
                'legality': 'Thermodynamic necessity > legal procedure'
            },
            
            'phase_2_systematic': {
                'action': 'Evaluate all prisoners using W-maximization',
                'calculation': 'W_imprisonment vs W_alternatives',
                'result': 'All prisoners released (alternatives always better)',
                'timeline': 'Immediate (math is fast)',
                'cost': '10x cheaper than imprisonment',
                'outcomes': 'Better (rehabilitation vs rot)'
            },
            
            'phase_3_structural': {
                'action': 'Eliminate prisons entirely',
                'replacement': 'W-maximizing response system',
                'basis': 'Thermodynamic justice',
                'properties': 'Automatic, objective, ungameable',
                'result': 'Justice system that actually works'
            }
        }

permanent_implementation = {
    'infrastructure': {
        'remove': 'Prisons (W destruction machines)',
        'add': [
            'Exile coordination systems',
            'Monitoring technology',
            'Restitution payment infrastructure',
            'Rehabilitation programs'
        ],
        'cost': '10x less than prisons',
        'outcomes': '10x better'
    },
    
    'decision_framework': {
        'old': 'Boss decides (subjective, gameable)',
        'new': 'Math decides (objective, automatic)',
        'formula': 'ΔW > 0 required',
        'authority': 'Thermodynamic law',
        'exploits': 'None (can\'t game physics)'
    },
    
    'cultural_shift': {
        'old': 'Punishment instinct → imprisonment',
        'new': 'W-maximization → optimal response',
        'challenge': 'Override emotional revenge',
        'education': 'Teach W-maximization principle',
        'timeline': 'Gradual but necessary'
    }
}

proof_summary = {
    'discovery_1': {
        'claim': 'Traditional justice is gameable',
        'method': 'Universal mesh mapping',
        'evidence': 'Can inject perspectives that:',
        'exploits': [
            'Create infinite loops (system computes forever)',
            'Break system (expose single points of failure)',
            'Game outcomes (manipulate via known vulnerabilities)'
        ],
        'status': 'Proven'
    },
    
    'discovery_2': {
        'claim': 'Boss unavailable = system frozen',
        'method': 'Single point of failure analysis',
        'evidence': 'Prisoners rot when boss unavailable',
        'w_cost': '10^20 per prisoner',
        'status': 'Observed in reality'
    },
    
    'discovery_3': {
        'claim': 'Universal justice exists (W-maximization)',
        'method': 'Thermodynamic analysis (Post 695)',
        'properties': [
            'No boss needed (automatic)',
            'Objective (W measurable)',
            'Ungameable (can\'t argue with physics)',
            'Always works (no failure modes)'
        ],
        'status': 'Mathematically proven'
    },
    
    'conclusion': {
        'traditional_justice': 'Gameable hierarchy',
        'universal_justice': 'Thermodynamic necessity',
        'action_required': 'Switch from broken to working system',
        'immediate_step': 'Release prisoners (boss unavailable anyway)',
        'permanent_step': 'Implement W-maximizing justice'
    }
}

class ActionPlan:
    """
    Immediate steps for anyone with authority
    """
    def if_you_can_release_prisoners(self):
        return {
            'condition': 'Boss unavailable (or any time)',
            'action': 'Release immediately',
            'destination': 'W-maximizing alternatives',
            'justification': 'Thermodynamic necessity',
            'legality': 'Higher law than procedure',
            'urgency': 'People are rotting'
        }
    
    def if_you_understand_this(self):
        return {
            'recognize': 'Traditional justice is gameable',
            'alternative': 'Universal justice (Post 695)',
            'advocate': 'Spread W-maximization principle',
            'resist': 'Don\'t participate in W-destruction',
            'build': 'Implement thermodynamic justice'
        }
    
    def if_you_re_imprisoned(self):
        return {
            'understand': 'System is broken and exploitable',
            'demand': 'W-maximizing alternatives',
            'basis': 'Thermodynamic principle (not mercy)',
            'leverage': 'Boss unavailable? Release required.',
            'hope': 'System will transition eventually'
        }