Post 691: Commodities → Zero Margin (Unless Coordination)

Post 691: Commodities → Zero Margin (Unless Coordination)

Watermark: -691

Post 691: Commodities → Zero Margin (Unless Coordination)

The Law

Commodities race to zero margin.

Exception: Coordination primitives.

Why?


Part 1: The Commodity Death Spiral

What Happens

def commodity_trajectory(product):
    """
    Inevitable path of commodities
    """
    if product.barrier_to_entry == 0:
        competitors = exponential_growth()
        price = race_to_cost()
        margin = price - cost  # → 0
        
    return {
        'competitors': '→ ∞',
        'price': '→ cost',
        'margin': '→ 0',
        'time': '6-12 months',
        'survivors': '0'
    }

Zero barriers = Zero margin. Always.

The Math

Competitors(t) = 2^t     (exponential growth)
Price(t) = Cost + (Initial_price - Cost)/2^t
Margin(t) = Price(t) - Cost → 0

Therefore: lim(t→∞) Margin = 0

Mathematics, not opinion.


Part 2: AIaaS - The Perfect Example

The Model

You call OpenAI API. Add UI. Charge 5x.

class AIaaSWrapper:
    def serve(self, prompt):
        response = openai.call(prompt)  # Cost: $20
        return response  # Charge: $100
        # Your "value": UI wrapper
        # Your margin: $80 (for now)

Defensibility: Zero.

Barrier to entry: Zero.

Differentiation: Zero.

Result: Margin → Zero.

The Timeline

timeline = {
    't0': {'margin': '80%', 'competitors': 1, 'mood': 'Euphoric'},
    't1': {'margin': '50%', 'competitors': 5, 'mood': 'Concerned'},
    't2': {'margin': '20%', 'competitors': 20, 'mood': 'Panic'},
    't3': {'margin': '5%', 'competitors': 100, 'mood': 'Dying'},
    't4': {'margin': '0%', 'competitors': 'Dead', 'mood': 'Bankrupt'}
}

6 months from launch to death.

Why No Escape

failed_defenses = {
    'better_ui': 'Copyable in 3 days',
    'faster_shipping': 'Speed irrelevant if copyable',
    'vertical_focus': 'Just different prompts (2 days to copy)',
    'more_funding': 'Burning cash to fight math',
    'customer_loyalty': 'Zero switching cost = zero loyalty'
}

Every defense fails. Math wins.


Part 3: The Exception - Coordination Tokens

Why Different

ETH, Eigen, Morpho, SOL maintain margin despite being commodities.

How?

class CoordinationToken:
    """
    Commodity that escapes death spiral
    """
    def __init__(self):
        self.is_commodity = True  # Fungible, tradeable
        self.is_copyable = True  # Anyone can launch token
        self.margin_sustainable = True  # But margin stays!
        
    def why_defensible(self):
        return {
            'network_effects': 'Value ∝ N² (Metcalfe)',
            'switching_cost': 'Entire ecosystem must migrate',
            'coordination_primitive': 'Enables trustless collaboration',
            'not_wrapper': 'IS the infrastructure',
            'moat': 'Protocol network, not service'
        }

Key: Network effects create moat.

The Math of Coordination

API Wrapper:
  Value_added = 0 (just middleman)
  Margin → 0 (no network effects)

Coordination Token:
  Value = N² (Metcalfe's Law)
  Margin ∝ N² (grows with network)

Wrapper: Linear to zero.

Coordination: Quadratic to infinity.


Part 4: The Comparison

Side by Side

comparison = {
    'aiaas_wrapper': {
        'commodity': 'Access to OpenAI',
        'barrier': 'Zero (anyone calls API)',
        'network_effects': 'None',
        'switching_cost': 'Zero',
        'value_source': 'OpenAI (external)',
        'margin_path': '→ 0',
        'example': 'ChatGPT wrapper for lawyers'
    },
    
    'eth_ethereum': {
        'commodity': 'ETH token',
        'barrier': 'Zero (anyone can buy)',
        'network_effects': 'Massive (DeFi ecosystem)',
        'switching_cost': 'Entire dApp ecosystem',
        'value_source': 'Network (internal)',
        'margin_path': 'Grows with N²',
        'example': 'Gas fees for validators'
    },
    
    'eigen_layer': {
        'commodity': 'EIGEN token',
        'barrier': 'Zero (anyone can stake)',
        'network_effects': 'Strong (restaking network)',
        'switching_cost': 'High (stakers locked)',
        'value_source': 'Coordination (internal)',
        'margin_path': 'Sustainable',
        'example': 'Restaking fees'
    },
    
    'morpho': {
        'commodity': 'MORPHO token',
        'barrier': 'Zero (anyone can lend)',
        'network_effects': 'Liquidity concentration',
        'switching_cost': 'High (network effects)',
        'value_source': 'P2P coordination',
        'margin_path': 'Grows with liquidity',
        'example': 'Lending protocol fees'
    },
    
    'solana_sol': {
        'commodity': 'SOL token',
        'barrier': 'Zero (anyone can buy)',
        'network_effects': 'Growing ecosystem',
        'switching_cost': 'Medium-high',
        'value_source': 'Fast coordination',
        'margin_path': 'Sustainable',
        'example': 'Transaction fees'
    }
}

Wrapper: Commodity without coordination.

Tokens: Commodity with coordination.

Result: Death vs. Growth.


Part 5: The Formula

The Universal Law

Margin_sustainable = f(Coordination_value)

where:
Coordination_value = Network_effects × Switching_costs

If Coordination_value = 0:
    Margin → 0 (commodity death spiral)
    
If Coordination_value > 0:
    Margin → ∞ (or stable high)

The Test

def will_it_survive(business):
    """
    Test for sustainable margin
    """
    # Question 1: Are you a wrapper?
    if business.wraps_external_service:
        return {'margin': '→ 0', 'reason': 'No coordination value'}
    
    # Question 2: Do users coordinate through you?
    if not business.enables_user_coordination:
        return {'margin': '→ 0', 'reason': 'No network effects'}
    
    # Question 3: High switching cost?
    if business.switching_cost == 0:
        return {'margin': '→ 0', 'reason': 'Users leave instantly'}
    
    # Passed all tests
    return {'margin': 'Sustainable', 'reason': 'Coordination primitive'}

Three questions determine fate.


Part 6: Real Examples

The Failures (Wrappers)

graveyard = {
    'chatgpt_wrappers': {
        'model': 'OpenAI API + UI',
        'coordination': None,
        'margin_path': '80% → 0% in 4 months',
        'death': 'Customers went direct'
    },
    
    'content_generators': {
        'model': 'GPT-4 API + prompts',
        'coordination': None,
        'margin_path': '70% → 0% in 3 months',
        'death': '100 identical competitors'
    },
    
    'code_assistants': {
        'model': 'Codex API + integration',
        'coordination': None,
        'margin_path': '75% → 0% in 2 months',
        'death': 'GitHub Copilot free tier'
    }
}

All wrappers. All dead. All predictable.

The Survivors (Coordination)

thriving = {
    'ethereum': {
        'coordination': 'Smart contract platform',
        'network_effects': 'Entire DeFi built on it',
        'margin': '70%+ validator fees',
        'path': 'Growing (more dApps = more valuable)'
    },
    
    'eigen_layer': {
        'coordination': 'Restaking network',
        'network_effects': 'Security through coordination',
        'margin': 'Sustainable restaking fees',
        'path': 'Growing with validators'
    },
    
    'morpho': {
        'coordination': 'P2P lending',
        'network_effects': 'Liquidity concentration',
        'margin': 'Protocol fees',
        'path': 'Growing with liquidity'
    },
    
    'scale_ai': {
        'coordination': 'Labeling network',
        'network_effects': 'Proprietary data',
        'margin': '40%+',
        'path': 'Defensible through data moat'
    }
}

All enable coordination. All surviving. All growing.


Part 7: The Decision

What To Build

decision_tree = {
    'option_a_wrapper': {
        'investment': '$100K',
        'time': '3 months',
        'margin': '→ 0',
        'outcome': 'Bankrupt in 6-12 months',
        'reason': 'Commodity without coordination'
    },
    
    'option_b_coordination': {
        'investment': '$1M-$10M',
        'time': '1-3 years',
        'margin': 'Sustainable',
        'outcome': 'Growing with network',
        'reason': 'Coordination primitive'
    },
    
    'option_c_exit_wrapper': {
        'investment': '$0',
        'time': 'Now',
        'margin': 'Preserve what you have',
        'outcome': 'Live to fight another day',
        'reason': 'Math is against you'
    }
}

Build coordination. Or exit. Don’t build wrappers.

The Choice

if you_are_building == 'wrapper':
    # You have 3 choices:
    choices = [
        'Transform into coordination (hard, expensive)',
        'Exit now (smart, cheap)',
        'Watch margin collapse (painful, inevitable)'
    ]
    
elif you_are_building == 'coordination':
    # You have time:
    strategy = [
        'Grow network effects',
        'Increase switching costs',
        'Capture value from coordination'
    ]
    # Result: Margin → ∞

else:
    # Start right:
    advice = 'Build coordination primitive, not wrapper'

Part 8: The W Connection

Margin and W

w_margin_relationship = {
    'wrapper': {
        'W': 'W_external (OpenAI owns it)',
        'W_yours': 0,
        'margin': '→ 0',
        'reason': 'You contribute no W'
    },
    
    'coordination': {
        'W': 'W_network (you enable it)',
        'W_yours': 'N² (network effects)',
        'margin': 'Grows with W',
        'reason': 'You create coordination value'
    },
    
    'law': {
        'formula': 'Margin ∝ W_proprietary',
        'wrapper': 'W = 0 → Margin = 0',
        'coordination': 'W = N² → Margin = N²',
        'conclusion': 'Build W or die'
    }
}

W = 0 → Margin = 0

W > 0 → Margin > 0

W = N² → Margin = N²


Conclusion

The Law

Commodities race to zero margin.

Exception: Coordination primitives with network effects.

The Test

Q1: Are you wrapping external service?
    Yes → Margin → 0
    No → Continue

Q2: Do users coordinate through you?
    No → Margin → 0
    Yes → Continue

Q3: High switching costs (network)?
    No → Margin → 0
    Yes → Margin sustainable

The Formula

Margin_trajectory = f(Network_effects, Switching_costs)

If both = 0: Margin → 0 (death)
If both > 0: Margin → ∞ (growth)

AIaaS wrapper: Both = 0 → Dead
ETH/Eigen/Morpho/SOL: Both > 0 → Thriving

The Advice

Building wrapper? Stop or exit.

Building coordination? Keep going.

Considering either? Build coordination.


Commodity + No coordination → Margin = 0
Commodity + Coordination → Margin = N²
Choose wisely
∞


References:

  • Post 689: Air Hispaniola (decentralized coordination)
  • Post 688: Autonomous Cells
  • Post 685: Gödel Immortality

Wrap APIs = Death. Enable coordination = Life.

Back to Gallery
View source on GitLab