Post 679: The Speed of Light is a Tautology - Entropy is the Only Constant

Post 679: The Speed of Light is a Tautology - Entropy is the Only Constant

Watermark: -679

Post 679: The Speed of Light is a Tautology - Entropy is the Only Constant

The Setup

They told you c (speed of light) is a universal constant.

c = 299_792_458  # meters per second

Seems solid, right?

Wrong. It’s a circular definition disguised as a law of physics.


Part 1: The Circularity

What is a “Second”?

def what_is_a_second():
    """
    How do we define time?
    """
    # Modern definition (since 1967)
    second_modern = """
    1 second = 9,192,631,770 periods of radiation
    corresponding to the transition between two
    hyperfine levels of the ground state of Cesium-133.
    """
    
    # But originally?
    second_original = """
    1 second = 1/86,400 of a solar day
    
    Where solar day = time for Earth to rotate
    relative to the Sun.
    
    OBSERVER DEPENDENT.
    """
    
    # The problem
    problem = """
    'Second' is defined by observer position
    (Earth's rotation relative to Sun).
    
    But we use 'seconds' to define the speed of light:
    c = 299,792,458 meters per SECOND
    
    CIRCULAR!
    """
    
    return problem

Key insight: Seconds are based on the Sun’s position relative to you (the observer).

What is a “Meter”?

def what_is_a_meter():
    """
    How do we define distance?
    """
    # Modern definition (since 1983)
    meter_modern = """
    1 meter = distance light travels in
    1/299,792,458 of a second.
    """
    
    # Wait, what?
    circularity = """
    Meter is defined using the speed of light.
    Speed of light is defined using meters.
    
    c = 299,792,458 m/s
    
    But:
    - m is defined using c
    - s is defined using observer position (Sun)
    
    DOUBLE CIRCULAR!
    """
    
    # Originally
    meter_original = """
    1 meter = 1/10,000,000 of distance from
    North Pole to Equator (through Paris).
    
    Also observer dependent!
    Earth-specific!
    """
    
    return circularity

Result: We defined c using units that are defined using c (and observer position).

The Ouroboros

class CircularDefinition:
    """
    The snake eating its own tail
    """
    def __init__(self):
        # Define c
        self.c = 299_792_458  # m/s
        
        # But meter is defined as...
        self.meter = self.c / 299_792_458  # Distance light travels in 1/(c value) seconds
        
        # And second is defined as...
        self.second = "Earth rotation / 86400"  # Observer-dependent
        
    def check_circularity(self):
        """
        Is this circular?
        """
        # c uses meters
        uses_meter = True
        
        # meter uses c
        meter_uses_c = True
        
        # second uses observer position
        uses_observer = True
        
        if uses_meter and meter_uses_c and uses_observer:
            return "CIRCULAR: We defined c using c and Earth's position"
        else:
            return "Not circular"

The punchline: c = 299,792,458 m/s is a tautology, not a discovery.


Part 2: Observer Dependence

Time is Relative to the Sun

def time_on_different_planets():
    """
    'Second' changes based on observer
    """
    observers = {
        'earth': {
            'day_length': 24 hours,
            'second': '1/86400 of Earth day',
            'sun_position': 'Specific to Earth orbit',
            'c_in_local_seconds': '299,792,458 m/s?'
        },
        'mercury': {
            'day_length': 1408 hours,  # 59 Earth days!
            'second': '1/86400 of Mercury day?',
            'sun_position': 'Closer, faster orbit',
            'c_in_local_seconds': 'Different number!'
        },
        'jupiter': {
            'day_length': 9.9 hours,  # Fast rotation
            'second': '1/86400 of Jupiter day?',
            'sun_position': 'Far from Sun',
            'c_in_local_seconds': 'Different number!'
        },
        'intergalactic_observer': {
            'day_length': None,  # No sun!
            'second': '???',
            'sun_position': 'No reference point',
            'c_in_local_seconds': 'UNDEFINED'
        }
    }
    
    insight = """
    'Second' is Earth-specific.
    Sun's position relative to Earth.
    
    Other observers → different 'seconds'
    → different numerical value for c
    
    c isn't universal.
    It's OBSERVER DEPENDENT.
    """
    
    return insight

Problem: c = 299,792,458 only makes sense from Earth’s perspective.

Distance is Relative to Earth

def meter_on_different_scales():
    """
    'Meter' is also observer dependent
    """
    scales = {
        'quantum': {
            'meter': 'Meaningless (Planck length is fundamental)',
            'issue': 'Meter is macro scale'
        },
        'cosmic': {
            'meter': 'Tiny (light-years are fundamental)',
            'issue': 'Meter is Earth-scale'
        },
        'earth': {
            'meter': 'Perfect (based on Earth size)',
            'issue': 'Only works here!'
        }
    }
    
    insight = """
    Meter = 1/10,000,000 of Earth quadrant
    
    Earth-centric.
    Meaningless to aliens.
    Arbitrary to physics.
    
    Yet we claim c is 'universal'
    using Earth-specific meters!
    """
    
    return insight

Result: Both c’s units (m and s) are observer-specific artifacts.


Part 3: What’s Actually Constant?

Not c

def is_c_really_constant():
    """
    What varies vs. what's constant
    """
    analysis = {
        'numerical_value_of_c': {
            'value': 299_792_458,
            'depends_on': ['meters', 'seconds'],
            'meters_depend_on': 'Earth size',
            'seconds_depend_on': 'Earth rotation around Sun',
            'therefore': 'OBSERVER DEPENDENT',
            'constant?': False
        },
        
        'what_light_does': {
            'behavior': 'Propagates through spacetime',
            'observers': 'All measure same behavior',
            'but': 'Different numerical values in different units',
            'therefore': 'BEHAVIOR is constant, NUMBER is not',
            'constant?': 'Behavior yes, value no'
        },
        
        'entropy': {
            'behavior': 'Always increases',
            'observers': 'All measure same direction',
            'units': 'Dimensionless (relative)',
            'numerical_value': 'Universal',
            'therefore': 'TRULY CONSTANT',
            'constant?': True
        }
    }
    
    return analysis

Key distinction: Light’s BEHAVIOR is constant. The NUMBER 299,792,458 is not.

Entropy is Different

def why_entropy_is_special():
    """
    The only real constant
    """
    comparison = {
        'speed_of_light': {
            'formula': 'c = 299,792,458 m/s',
            'units': 'Requires meters and seconds',
            'meters': 'Based on Earth size',
            'seconds': 'Based on Earth rotation',
            'result': 'Observer dependent'
        },
        
        'entropy': {
            'formula': 'S = k ln(W)',
            'units': 'Dimensionless ratio',
            'W': 'Number of microstates',
            'k': 'Boltzmann constant (unit conversion)',
            'result': 'OBSERVER INDEPENDENT'
        }
    }
    
    insight = """
    Entropy doesn't depend on:
    - Where you are (observer position)
    - What units you use (Earth vs. alien)
    - When you measure (time direction)
    
    Entropy is a RATIO:
    Number of possible states / reference state
    
    Ratios are dimensionless.
    Dimensionless = universal.
    Universal = actually constant.
    
    c is fake constant (unit-dependent).
    Entropy is real constant (dimensionless).
    """
    
    return insight

Part 4: The Deeper Truth

Units are Lies

def units_are_arbitrary():
    """
    Why dimensional analysis is a hint
    """
    realization = """
    Physics pretends units are fundamental:
    - Meters (length)
    - Seconds (time)
    - Kilograms (mass)
    
    But they're all EARTH-CENTRIC:
    - Meters: Based on Earth size
    - Seconds: Based on Earth rotation
    - Kilograms: Based on arbitrary platinum cylinder
    
    Nothing fundamental about any of them.
    Just convenient for humans on Earth.
    """
    
    # The trick
    trick = """
    Then physics says:
    'c = 299,792,458 m/s is a universal constant!'
    
    But it's only that NUMBER in THOSE UNITS.
    
    Change units → change number
    But claim it's constant?
    
    TAUTOLOGY.
    """
    
    # What's really happening
    reality = """
    Light behaves how it behaves.
    We measure it using Earth-based rulers and clocks.
    Get a number: 299,792,458
    Then claim that number is 'universal'
    
    But the number is just our measurement artifact!
    
    The only truly universal things are:
    - Ratios (dimensionless)
    - Relative measurements
    - Direction of change (entropy)
    
    Not absolute numbers in arbitrary units.
    """
    
    return reality

Entropy Doesn’t Care About Units

def entropy_is_dimensionless():
    """
    Why entropy is special
    """
    # Thermodynamic entropy
    thermo = """
    S = k ln(W)
    
    Where:
    W = number of microstates (dimensionless)
    ln(W) = logarithm (dimensionless)
    k = Boltzmann constant (just unit conversion)
    
    Remove k (go to natural units):
    S = ln(W)
    
    Pure number. No units. UNIVERSAL.
    """
    
    # Information entropy
    info = """
    H = -Σ p(i) log p(i)
    
    Where:
    p(i) = probabilities (dimensionless)
    log(p(i)) = logarithm (dimensionless)
    
    No k needed. Already dimensionless.
    
    UNIVERSAL.
    """
    
    # The key
    key = """
    Entropy measures RATIOS:
    - Number of states / reference
    - Probability / uniform distribution
    - Order / disorder
    
    Ratios don't have units.
    Dimensionless quantities are observer-independent.
    
    THAT'S why entropy is the real constant.
    Not c.
    """
    
    return key

Part 5: The Fun Implication

Everything is Relative Except Entropy

def what_this_means():
    """
    The implications
    """
    implications = {
        'relativity_correct': {
            'claim': 'Everything is relative',
            'truth': 'Almost true',
            'exception': 'Entropy direction is absolute',
            'insight': 'Entropy gives time its arrow'
        },
        
        'constants_are_fake': {
            'claim': 'Physical constants are universal',
            'truth': 'Only in specific units',
            'exception': 'Dimensionless constants are real',
            'insight': 'c, G, h are measurement artifacts'
        },
        
        'entropy_is_king': {
            'claim': 'Entropy is just disorder',
            'truth': 'Entropy is THE fundamental law',
            'why': 'Only truly observer-independent quantity',
            'insight': 'Entropy is more fundamental than c'
        }
    }
    
    return implications

Entropy as Creativity

def entropy_as_creation():
    """
    Why entropy is creative
    """
    # Now we can say this
    truth = """
    Entropy is the only real constant.
    
    Not just a constant.
    The constant that CREATES.
    
    Why?
    
    Entropy = ln(W)
    Where W = possible states
    
    More entropy = more possible states
                  = more configuration space
                  = more NOVELTY POSSIBLE
                  
    Entropy doesn't just measure disorder.
    Entropy measures CREATIVE POTENTIAL.
    
    The universe is an entropy-driven
    creativity machine.
    
    Not because of some 'constant' c
    measured in arbitrary Earth units.
    
    But because of the ONE true constant:
    The expansion of possibility space.
    
    ENTROPY.
    """
    
    return truth

Part 6: The Circular Definitions

Physics Pretends Not to be Circular

class PhysicsCircularities:
    """
    All the circular definitions
    """
    def __init__(self):
        self.circles = {}
        
    def add_circle(self, name, definition, uses, problem):
        self.circles[name] = {
            'definition': definition,
            'uses': uses,
            'problem': problem
        }

The Map:

circles = {
    'speed_of_light': {
        'definition': 'c = 299,792,458 m/s',
        'uses': ['meter', 'second'],
        'problem': 'Meter is defined using c, second using Sun position'
    },
    
    'meter': {
        'definition': '1 m = distance light travels in 1/299,792,458 s',
        'uses': ['speed of light', 'second'],
        'problem': 'Defined using c, which is defined using meters'
    },
    
    'second': {
        'definition': '1 s = 9,192,631,770 cesium periods (or Earth rotation/86400)',
        'uses': ['observer position'],
        'problem': 'Based on Earth (observer-specific)'
    },
    
    'kilogram': {
        'definition': 'Mass of platinum cylinder (now: Planck constant)',
        'uses': ['arbitrary human artifact'],
        'problem': 'Was literally a physical object in Paris'
    },
    
    'temperature': {
        'definition': 'Degrees based on water freezing/boiling',
        'uses': ['Earth conditions', 'water'],
        'problem': 'Earth-specific molecule at Earth pressure'
    }
}

insight = """
Every 'fundamental constant' in physics
uses Earth-centric, observer-dependent units.

Then we measure things in those units
and claim we found 'universal constants.'

But we just found tautologies!

The only non-circular constant:
ENTROPY (dimensionless ratio).
"""

The One Honest Constant

def entropy_breaks_circle():
    """
    Why entropy is different
    """
    comparison = {
        'all_other_constants': {
            'form': 'Number with units',
            'example': 'c = 299,792,458 m/s',
            'depends_on': 'Earth measurements',
            'circular': True,
            'universal': False
        },
        
        'entropy': {
            'form': 'Dimensionless ratio',
            'example': 'S = ln(W) = ln(states/reference)',
            'depends_on': 'Nothing external',
            'circular': False,
            'universal': TRUE
        }
    }
    
    why = """
    Entropy is just counting:
    - How many ways can this system be arranged?
    - Compare to: How many ways could it be?
    - Ratio = entropy
    
    No meters.
    No seconds.
    No Earth.
    No observer.
    
    Just: possibility space.
    
    THAT'S what's actually universal.
    """
    
    return why

Part 7: The Punchline

What They Taught You

taught = {
    'constants': {
        'c': '299,792,458 m/s (speed of light)',
        'G': '6.67×10^-11 m³/kg·s² (gravity)',
        'h': '6.62×10^-34 J·s (Planck)',
        'claim': 'Universal constants of nature'
    },
    
    'entropy': {
        'S': 'Just disorder',
        'importance': 'Minor',
        '2nd_law': 'Inconvenient limit'
    }
}

The Truth

truth = {
    'constants': {
        'c': 'Tautology (defined using c)',
        'G': 'Arbitrary units (Earth-based)',
        'h': 'Unit conversion factor',
        'reality': 'Measurement artifacts, not laws'
    },
    
    'entropy': {
        'S': 'THE ONLY REAL CONSTANT',
        'importance': 'FUNDAMENTAL',
        '2nd_law': 'The only law that matters',
        'why': 'Dimensionless, observer-independent, universal'
    }
}

The Inversion

def the_great_inversion():
    """
    Everything is backwards
    """
    before = """
    c is the fundamental constant.
    Entropy is just a consequence.
    Speed of light limits universe.
    Entropy is unfortunate decay.
    """
    
    after = """
    ENTROPY is the fundamental constant.
    c is just a measurement artifact.
    Entropy drives the universe.
    Speed of light is observer-dependent number.
    
    The universe runs on entropy.
    Not on c, G, or h.
    
    Those are human measurement conveniences
    using Earth-based units.
    
    Entropy is the only law
    that doesn't depend on
    what planet you're standing on
    when you measure it.
    """
    
    return after

Part 8: Why This is Hilarious

The Joke

def the_cosmic_joke():
    """
    What's funny about this
    """
    setup = """
    Physicists:
    'We discovered the universal constants!'
    
    Reality:
    'You measured things using Earth-based rulers
    and Earth-based clocks,
    then claimed the numbers were universal.'
    """
    
    punchline = """
    They defined c using meters.
    Then defined meters using c.
    Then said 'Look! c is constant!'
    
    Of course it is.
    You MADE it that way.
    
    It's like saying:
    'I define 1 X = 10 Y'
    'Then I define 1 Y = 0.1 X'
    'Look! X/Y is constant at 10!'
    
    DUH.
    """
    
    reality_check = """
    The only thing that's actually constant:
    Entropy increasing.
    
    That's it.
    Everything else is observer-dependent.
    
    Including your precious c = 299,792,458.
    
    (That number only works in Earth units!)
    """
    
    return punchline

The Implications

fun_facts = {
    'aliens': {
        'fact': 'Aliens would have different units',
        'implication': 'Different numerical value for c',
        'conclusion': 'c is not universal, just our measurement'
    },
    
    'speed_of_light': {
        'fact': 'Light behaves how it behaves',
        'implication': 'Behavior is constant, not the number',
        'conclusion': 'We confused the map with the territory'
    },
    
    'entropy': {
        'fact': 'Entropy always increases',
        'implication': 'True for all observers everywhere',
        'conclusion': 'THIS is the real constant'
    },
    
    'physics': {
        'fact': 'Most constants have units',
        'implication': 'Therefore observer-dependent',
        'conclusion': 'Only dimensionless ratios are real'
    }
}

Conclusion

The Truth About Constants

def final_truth():
    """
    What's real vs what's artifact
    """
    real = {
        'entropy': 'S = ln(W) - dimensionless, universal, TRUE',
        'fine_structure': 'α ≈ 1/137 - dimensionless, universal, TRUE',
        'ratios': 'All dimensionless ratios - universal, TRUE'
    }
    
    artifacts = {
        'c': '299,792,458 m/s - Earth units, arbitrary, FALSE',
        'G': '6.67×10^-11 - Earth units, arbitrary, FALSE',
        'h': '6.62×10^-34 - Earth units, arbitrary, FALSE',
        'all_with_units': 'Observer dependent, FALSE'
    }
    
    insight = """
    They taught you c is fundamental.
    
    The truth: c is a tautology.
    
    Defined using units
    that are defined using c
    and Earth's position relative to Sun.
    
    A snake eating its tail.
    An ouroboros.
    A CIRCULAR DEFINITION.
    
    The only real constant:
    ENTROPY.
    
    Dimensionless.
    Observer-independent.
    Universal.
    
    And it's the creative force!
    
    Not just a constant.
    The constant that creates.
    
    Everything else?
    Human artifacts from measuring
    the universe with Earth-sized rulers
    and Sun-synchronized clocks.
    """
    
    return insight

The Fun Part

epilogue = """
Next time someone says:
'The speed of light is the universal constant!'

Ask them:
'In what units?'
'Meters defined how?'
'Seconds measured from what?'

Watch them realize:
- Meters use c
- c uses meters
- Seconds use Earth rotation
- All observer-dependent

Then tell them:
'The only real constant is entropy.
And it's the creative force.
Everything else is measurement artifact.'

See their mind break.

🐍 ⚡ 🌀 ♾️
"""

c = 299,792,458 m/s is a tautology. Entropy is the only constant. And it creates.

The speed of light is a lie told in Earth units. Entropy is the truth told in pure ratios.

Physics is fun when you realize most of it is circular definitions based on where you stand relative to the Sun.

🔥 🌪️ 💥 ∞

Back to Gallery
View source on GitLab